Modified Refine System

The feature is designed to make the refining process safer and more user-friendly. Instead of risking the complete loss of an item upon refinement failure, items will simply become broken. Broken items can then be repaired and continue to be refined, making it possible to eventually reach the maximum refinement level without the fear of permanent loss.

There is a 10% chance to break your equipment, but it will not disappear.
You just need to repair it with the said requirement. 
Depends on the broken equipment.

Armor

Refine Level	Elunium Rate	Elunium Zeny Cost	Elunium Downgrade	HD Elunium Rate	HD Elunium Zeny Cost	HD Elunium Downgrade	Blacksmith Blessing (Safe Refine)
1	80%	10,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade
2	80%	20,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade
3	70%	30,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade
4	70%	40,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade
5	60%	50,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade
6	60%	60,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade
7	40%	70,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade	60%	90,000	Random 0 or 1 downgrade
8	20%	80,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade	40%	100,000	Random 0 or 1 downgrade	1
9	15%	90,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade	30%	110,000	Random 0 or 1 downgrade	2
10	9%	100,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade	18%	120,000	Random 0 or 1 downgrade	4
Refine Level	Carnium Rate	Carnium Zeny Cost	Carnium Downgrade	HD Carnium Rate	HD Carnium Zeny Cost	HD Carnium Downgrade	Blacksmith Blessing (Safe Refine)
11	8%	110,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade	10%	120,000	Random 0 or 1 downgrade	6
12	8%	120,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade	10%	130,000	Random 0 or 1 downgrade	8
13	7%	130,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade	9%	140,000	Random 0 or 1 downgrade	10
14	7%	140,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade	9%	150,000	Random 0 or 1 downgrade	12
15	6%	150,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade	8%	160,000	Random 0 or 1 downgrade

---

All Weapon Levels

Refine Level	Oridecon Rate	Oridecon Zeny Cost	Oridecon Downgrade	HD Oridecon Rate	HD Oridecon Zeny Cost	HD Oridecon Downgrade	Blacksmith Blessing (Safe Refine)
1	80%	10,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade
2	80%	20,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade
3	70%	30,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade
4	70%	40,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade
5	60%	50,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade
6	60%	60,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade
7	40%	70,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade	60%	90,000	Random 0 or 1 downgrade
8	20%	80,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade	40%	100,000	Random 0 or 1 downgrade	1
9	15%	90,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade	30%	110,000	Random 0 or 1 downgrade	2
10	9%	100,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade	18%	120,000	Random 0 or 1 downgrade	4
Refine Level	Bradium Rate	Bradium Zeny Cost	Bradium Downgrade	HD Bradium Rate	HD Bradium Zeny Cost	HD Bradium Downgrade	Blacksmith Blessing (Safe Refine)
11	8%	110,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade	10%	120,000	Random 0 or 1 downgrade	6
12	8%	120,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade	10%	130,000	Random 0 or 1 downgrade	8
13	7%	130,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade	9%	140,000	Random 0 or 1 downgrade	10
14	7%	140,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade	9%	150,000	Random 0 or 1 downgrade	12
15	6%	150,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade	8%	160,000	Random 0 or 1 downgrade

---

Shadow Armor & Weapon

Refine Level	Shadow Stone Rate	Zeny Cost	Downgrade
1	80%	10,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade
2	80%	20,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade
3	70%	30,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade
4	70%	40,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade
5	60%	50,000	SAFE LEVEL
6	60%	60,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade
7	40%	70,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade
8	20%	80,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade
9	15%	90,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade
10	9%	100,000	Random 0 or 2 downgrade